The proprietor of a Stage Pleasurable Beach motel is fighting plans by the borough to receive his home as a result of eminent domain and switch it into a parking large amount.

Borough Council programs to introduce an ordinance Tuesday evening to negotiate acquisition of the Amethyst Seashore Motel, located a couple blocks from the community’s seaside and boardwalk. The 1 1/2-acre home sits at the corner of Arnold and Baltimore avenues following to a huge municipal parking ton.

It contains the 40-home motel — which has been in the Fernicola spouse and children considering the fact that 1962 and has been a motel considering that 1948 — as very well as a separate residence that the household rents out and motel parking.

Owner John Fernicola questioned the mayor and council’s motives for the action, citing a March 4 news write-up by The Coast Star in which Councilman Bob Santanello referenced the number of law enforcement phone calls at the motel in the last yr and Mayor Paul Kanitra claimed “other components and side effects related with the home are very well-recognised by the law enforcement and residents in this city.”

Fernicola feels the borough is punishing him for police phone calls to the assets in the past calendar year. The motel has experienced number of problems in excess of the many years, Fernicola insisted, and referred to as past yr an anomaly.

Though the motel generally takes in “winter guests,” which includes contractors and other locals, trouble commenced last yr when Fernicola claimed he had to go to Florida for procedure of wellness challenges. He left administrators running the motel and found a mess when he returned through the early times of the pandemic.

“When I received back in March, I found the hotel whole of their friends and a large amount of appealing persons that I wouldn’t have authorized,” he said.

When he tried using to evict a bunch of what he termed “bad characters” for triggering issues and not paying out rent, he was informed the governor’s eviction moratorium prevented him from ejecting approximately 30 lodgers occupying 15 rooms. At least two lodgers filed lawsuits final yr alleging they have been illegally locked out of the motel.

The motel was cited for violating the governor’s moratorium on evictions and authorized battles proceed over a few tenants.

Borough Law enforcement Chief Joseph Michigan claimed the motel has usually experienced difficulties, though calls past year had been “through the roof,” he mentioned.

“I’ve been a law enforcement officer here for 25 yrs. In the off-year, there’s absolutely a different clientele being there that is induced a large amount of problems for the police office,” Michigan reported. “That hotel has generally been in the off-time a haven for troubles.”

Phone calls have provided domestic disturbances, fights and drug-relevant challenges, but it’s not the only nearby motel with these forms of difficulties, the main extra. Though Fernicola claimed he cooperates with law enforcement, the chief explained “he cooperates when it is in his very best desire, I’ll just depart it at that.”

Fernicola challenged recommendations that the home is a nuisance and explained he is searching for documents on all police calls to his motel for the very last 5 decades. “We know around the past two months there’s only been 4 or 5 police calls,” he reported, and this common volume is all that will be found when searching over the past quite a few several years.

Fernicola responded that all inns in the borough have difficulties. He questioned the general public will need for using his house.

“We really don’t use eminent area to punish men and women … They don’t have to have a parking good deal. Which is an excuse,” he explained. “The previous detail anybody in that town would like is additional day-trippers and additional parking.”

Because of the lawful challenges concerned, Mayor Kanitra mentioned he could not go over the topic, but offered a lengthy assertion in which he explained a assembly Fernicola asked for almost a yr back in the course of which he available to sell the property to the borough “and had even proactively sketched out the variety of parking areas it could accommodate for us.”

“He seemed to be fine at that time with far more parking even although now he is striving to use that narrative negatively in the media.”

For much more than five months, the borough attempted to total an appraisal of the property, Kanitra claimed.

“Mr. Fernicola commenced stalling and dragging out the method. Inevitably, we as a Council arrived to the unanimous conclusion that it was in the best general public fascination to receive the residence one way or an additional. The home is contiguous to the other public parking heaps for the seaside and boardwalk where we continually have congestion. Mainly because of the seriously deteriorated form of the setting up, we believe demolition will be a simple and price tag-successful approach and finished quickly.”

Fernicola said that conference was originally prepared for a dialogue of his proposal for a new boutique hotel on the site, but the conversation turned when borough officials raised the plan of acquiring the home.

“We introduced ourselves in an open up, cost-free negotiation of ideas,” he explained. “One was building this new, beautiful lodge. The other was, if you do not want me to develop it, are you intrigued in just obtaining the land?”

He has been performing on plans for the new lodge for the previous four many years, Fernicola said, including that a zoning adjust that would have permitted that project to move ahead was never ever finalized by the borough.

As for the declare that he dragged out discussions with the borough past calendar year, Fernicola said he was being addressed for his health-related difficulties at the time and was not offered.

He designs to fight the borough’s attempts.

The Fernicola relatives has introduced an on the web petition in search of guidance for their energy and had attained extra than 630 signatures as of Monday afternoon. The borough council assembly is slated for 7:30 p.m. on Tuesday via Zoom.

Our journalism needs your guidance. You should subscribe today to

Matt Grey might be reached at